Richard Peltz, a professor at the University of Arkansas Bowen School of Law, has filed a lawsuit against two students who called him a racist.
The lawsuit names Valerie Nation and Chrishuana Clark, both third-year law students who have been involved with the school’s Black Law Students Association, along with Eric Spencer Buchanan, president of the W. Harold Flowers Law Society. The organizations are also named in the suit.
In the fall of 2005, Peltz gave a lecture in his constitutional law class that March 2007 letter circulated by the Black Law Students Association later described as a “hateful and inciting speech … used to attack and demean the black students in his class.” In light of this and other incidents, the BLSA asked that Peltz be reprimanded by the law school, barred from teaching required courses “where Black students would be required to have him as a professor,” and made to attend diversity training.
In his lawsuit, Peltz contends that these and other “false accusations of racism damaged plaintiff’s reputation, character and integrity in the Arkansas legal community.”
Last Thursday an attorney for Clark filed a motion to dismiss the lawsuit, contending that “an accusation by a plaintiff that a defendant has called him a racist, in the context of public discourse at a law school,” will not “support a claim for defamation.” The motion contends that Peltz “has embarked on a personal vendetta against two black law students and two predominantly black organizations based on what he perceives as their opposition to him or to his political views and legal theories.”

6 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 6, 2008 at 9:25 am
charlietekopp
I believe the word racist shouldn’t be used as easy as it sometimes is. Maybe this is right because theres simply no other way of regulating it?
May 6, 2008 at 9:59 am
Angus Johnston
What do you say to the attorney’s suggestion that a charge of racism is simply a part of normal “public discourse”?
May 6, 2008 at 10:08 am
charlietekopp
I believe that it’s quite an insult to call someone a racist. If one does, he should be prepared to proof it. If he cannot the victim should have the possibility to sue him.
If you regard it simply as a part of normal public discourse it will soon not be an insult anymore. Theres maybe a risk that being a racist will be totally normal and nothing to be ashamed of if the term is used to easy.
i believe its important that you do not accuse innocent people and if you do it might result in that no one will care being called a racist.
May 6, 2008 at 12:22 pm
Ervin Sholpnick
Too many lawyers.
May 6, 2008 at 12:29 pm
Angus Johnston
Charlie: Most insults aren’t libel. If you say that someone has used “hateful and inciting speech,” or even racist speech, that’s a matter of opinion, and opinions for the most part can’t be proven or disproven.
Ervin: Too many lawyers at a law school? Hard to imagine.
December 13, 2008 at 11:35 am
Prof Drops Suit Against Students Who Called Him Racist « studentactivism.net
[…] Events, Faculty, Litigation, Race Back in the spring, Arkansas law professor Richard Peltz brought a defamation lawsuit against two law students who had circulated a letter accusing him of racism in the classroom. At […]