Yesterday Yahoo put up a post on its search blog titled “Teens Don’t Know Who Osama Bin Laden Is, According to Yahoo! Search Trends.”
The story has been picked up by a long list of other outlets — PC Magazine and Gawker both claimed that “many” teens don’t know who Bin Laden was, while one site went so far as to claim that a “majority” are unaware. BoingBoing hedged its bets, claiming that “a non-insignificant number of teenagers in America do not know who Osama bin Laden is.”
But what did Yahoo’s published data actually show?
Not much, it turns out. According to the blogpost, “who is osama bin laden” was the fifth-most searched question relating to Bin Laden on Sunday, which made it more popular than questions about his height, but more popular than questions about his age. How many people searched that question? Yahoo doesn’t say. Could have been millions, could have been a handful. What it does say is that two thirds of those searching were between the ages of 13 and 17.
As for what this factoid means, I have a few thoughts. First of all, as I’ve suggested above, it doesn’t mean that large numbers of teens were asking this question. Again, we just don’t have any data on that. Also, even the fact that a high proportion of askers were young teens is ambiguous — I’d be inclined to guess that young people are more likely than older people to phrase search queries as questions. If that’s true, then the stat makes teens look comparatively less informed, because it excludes all the fortysomethings who didn’t recognize the name and just searched “osama bin laden” to find out.
I’d also question the assumption that anyone searching on “who is osama bin laden” has no idea who Bin Laden was. A Google search on the question shows that at various times in the last ten years it’s been asked by, among others, BBC News, the PBS Frontline documentary series, and the Canadian Broadcasting Commission.
“Who is Osama Bin Laden,” in other words, can be, and often is, used as a synonym for “Tell me some stuff about Osama Bin Laden.” And “tell me some stuff about Osama Bin Laden” is a perfectly reasonable request for a thirteen-year-old to have made last Sunday night.
Over at Mother Jones, Kevin Drum has pointed out that September 11, 2001 was almost ten years ago, and that for many of the folks in the 13-to-17 age bracket, it’s been a really long time since he was in the news. That’s a good point, and it would be worth pointing out if it had been demonstrated, as Drum suggests, that “a goodly number of teenagers don’t know who Osama bin Laden is.”
That’s the thing, though. It hasn’t.
Update | TechPresident covers much the same ground, with this lovely zinger: “We could just as easily reading the data as ‘Teenagers Eagerly Search Out Information on Current World Events, and Good for Them.’
Second Update | Inspired by Judith Butlertron’s suggestion, I just did Google searches on “who is barack obama” and “barack obama.” Turns out that adding the “who is” skews the results toward third-party, informational sources, and away from DNC/White House promotional materials. So the joke is on Yahoo, and everyone who promoted this meme — if you want to learn more about someone, starting your search with “who is…” appears to be the internet-savvy way to go about it.
Third Update | The ignorance being expressed in these snark stories really is astounding. Britain’s Daily Mail newspaper says, on no evidence at all, that teens “flooded … the internet” with “who is osama bin laden” queries, while Good magazine claims “thousands” asked the question. Good also claims that it’s “the fifth most popular Osama search,” rather than the fifth most popular Osama question, which is a very different thing. Glenn Beck has gotten into the act too, claiming — falsely — that the query “was one of the most popular tweets and searches over the past few days.”
Fourth Update | Oof. Megan McArdle of the Atlantic, who uncovered the fake MLK/OBL quote earlier this week, has fallen for the Yahoo crap. Worse yet, she’s titled her blogpost on the story “Youth Culture.”
11 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 4, 2011 at 5:00 pm
judith.butlertron
I’m vaguely entertained by the idea that these so-called “journalists” are genuinely unaware that a search string including a “who is” will very likely find you a great deal of in-depth information on that person, without having to slog through the hundreds of recent, heavily-padded, or partisan news articles that would result from searching only a name.
May 4, 2011 at 6:51 pm
Angus Johnston
Thanks for the heads-up, JBT! I actually didn’t know that adding the “who is” would improve the results, but I did some poking around and it seems to check out. I’ve updated the post.
May 4, 2011 at 9:10 pm
"MerlinYoda"
Yes, maybe *some* were “tech savvy” enough and included the “who is” to they and get more informational results rather than, say, current events … but that doesn’t at all excuse the kids that used that search term (i.e. those that where actually asking because they did not know) … and it *certainly* doesn’t excuse those that *tweeted* to ask who Osama Bin Laden is/was as I seriously doubt that there are that many teenagers and young adults (and possibly some adults as well) that were simply trying to be ironic/sarcastic/flippant in their tweets.
The sad truth seems to be that there are at least a noticeable amount of the younger generation (Gen Z? Millennials? Have they decided on a label yet?) have absolutely *no* clue of the identity of the evil SOB that was behind the 9/11 attacks (full disclosure: I’m on the cusp of Gen X and Gen Y, I fit the Gen Y “profile” more than the Gen X one though). I mean, we’re not talking trivial details like how many passengers were on board United flight 93. We’re talking some *very troubling* ignorance of history and current events if they actually don’t know something like this!
May 4, 2011 at 10:13 pm
Angus Johnston
MY, the number of people who tweeted unironically that they didn’t know who Bin Laden was seems to have been in the low dozens. Like two dozen, maybe fewer. Is that “a noticeable amount of the younger generation”? It’s noticeable in the sense that people noticed it, I suppose, but is it meaningful? Representative? Significant in any real way?
I say it’s not.
May 4, 2011 at 10:28 pm
Sofia
Honestly, what’s the point of such a story? Why insult and insult and insult the upcoming generation? It’s always those things like we’re so clueless and stupid and messed up. Whose fault is that? If kids/teens don’t know the identity of an infamous man, perhaps the headline should actually address something or be productive somehow like, “Parents and schools must more directly address current events and world issues”.
Still, all over facebook, RIGHT when the news came out, loads and loads of my young, teenage friends were having lovely philosophical discussions about whether we should be rejoicing in killing this man, if it’s wrong, all of the stuff that he did, is it worth it… (And some wrote the simple “USA! USA! USA!”) Even the ignorant know what’s up. They knew the name.
May 5, 2011 at 10:29 am
Also, These Are People Who Search With Yahoo - Hit & Run : Reason Magazine
[…] and the story struck a chord with writers eager to fret about ignorant kids. But as Angus Johnston writes, that isn't actually what the data reveal: According to the blogpost, "who is osama bin laden" was […]
May 5, 2011 at 10:48 am
Also, These Are People Who Search With Yahoo | Daily Libertarian
[…] and the story struck a chord with writers eager to fret about ignorant kids. But as Angus Johnston writes, that isn’t actually what the data reveal: According to the blogpost, “who is osama bin […]
May 5, 2011 at 12:08 pm
kukkumol
Great goin pakis…ISI i know yesterday was black day for you coz u lost the most important person of your team who was living in your military base in 3000 sq million mansion and you were successful to hide him since past few years but US govt without informing you carried an operation and killed your martyr. I feel for you they didnt even give u time to relocate osama from his hiding in your backyard. My heartful condolences to pakistani government and ISI…..Next time you have to sign a treaty with US govt stating that they should inform you well in advance before carryin out such mission coz you should get time to relocate your employees of terror.
Note: Not for good paki citizens..not agains pakistani citizens but the failure govt n ISI
May 5, 2011 at 12:20 pm
Also, These Are People Who Search With Yahoo | Yahoo
[…] tο tatter аbουt ignorant kids. Bυt аѕ Angus Johnston writes, thаt isn’t indeed whаt thе information reveal: According tο thе […]
May 7, 2011 at 7:35 pm
Deborah
Great article about exactly what I was soooo frustated about in my article! (http://restoringtruthiness.org/2277/fox-news-blames-teachers-for-yahoo-claim-that-%E2%80%9Cteens-don%E2%80%99t-know-who-osama-bin-laden-is).
I had to quote you in regards to what Yahoo’s published data actually show because, I agree, without the actual numbers, the data doesn’t mean anything.
Fox News went even further with this “news” to spend much of the day to attack teachers and the public school system for allegedly not teaching about bin Laden.
All this based on some skimpy statistics from Yahoo!.
May 8, 2011 at 12:18 pm
Sunday Reading « zunguzungu
[…] lots of young people were googling “who is osama bin laden,” maybe), Angus Johnston is there to bring the knowledge: First of all, as I’ve suggested above, it doesn’t mean that large […]