This is totally off topic, but it’s burning up my Twitter feed and I just need to get it off my chest.
A bizarre video was recently posted to YouTube of Bishop Eddie Long being “crowned” at his church in a truly weird ritual. In the video, a “rabbi” named Ralph Messer wraps Long in what he describes as a 300-year-old “Holocaust scroll,” then drapes him in a shawl and hoists him in the air before declaring him a king.
It’s all very strange, not least because Long, the pastor of an Atlanta megachurch, was disgraced last year in a scandal involving his sexual relationships with at least four underage parishoners. (Long has been vocally anti-gay throughout his career, and the parishoners were male.)
There’s nothing that’s not creepy about the whole thing, and it’s been greeted with the mockery it deserves, but there’s one piece of the story that hasn’t gotten a lot of attention but should:
Rabbi Ralph Messer isn’t Jewish.
Messer is a proponent of so-called Messianic Judaism, a religious movement founded in the 1960s that wraps evangelical Christian theology in Jewish cultural trappings.
Put simply, it’s a Christian movement. Messer is a Christian minister.
And despite Messer’s claim to be acting “on behalf of the Jewish people and the land of Israel,” there’s nothing Jewish about the performance he put on at Long’s church. Neither the ritual nor the language of Messer’s act have any basis in Jewish traditions, while his repeated references to the divinity of Jesus and quotations from the Christian bible make his actual theology clear.
Also, the “priceless” Torah scroll Messer wraps Long in is almost certainly a fake. As you can see at 5:15 in the video, the thing is held together with scotch tape.
Oh, and one more tip for “Rabbi” Messer, if he’s reading this. The name of the Nazi concentration camp where you claim you found that scroll? It’s Auschwitz-Birkenau, not “Auschwitz and Birkendal.”
Update | A bible scholar lists 27 ways in which Messer’s performance misrepresented Jewish and Christian religious tradition.
Second Update | The “Messianic Judaism” movement repudiates Messer too: “Ralph Messer is not affiliated with the mainstream Messianic Jewish movement, nor is he a legitimately ordained Messianic Rabbi.” (More here and here.)
53 comments
Comments feed for this article
February 2, 2012 at 4:50 pm
tigtog
Thanks, from this side of the really big pond I was wondering who the hell Eddie Long even was, and now I know.
Understatement of the year, and it’s only just February. Well done.
February 2, 2012 at 5:16 pm
Pastor Ronson Hall
Wow…Again.
February 2, 2012 at 7:03 pm
eMatters
What?! You mean the Israelites didn’t have Scotch tape? (I saw that as well and laughed).
That video was such a train wreck! This was just one more reason.
That Long was do something so ridiculous shouldn’t surprise us, but that people still worship him is troubling.
February 2, 2012 at 7:22 pm
Judy
If you don’t stand up for JESUS, you will FALL for anything. Some people need to read the bible instead of listing to the devil.
February 2, 2012 at 8:02 pm
LM
Im so confused! The same thing took place at Word Of Faith International Christian Center in Southfield, Michigan with Bishop Keith A. Butler. I was there when they gave him the SCROLLS. The last time I was there theey were kept in a secure case in the lobby.
I need to pray. Im just confused
http://www.woficc.com
February 2, 2012 at 9:27 pm
Dear Eddie Long, You’re a King? iRebuke It | Awesomely Luvvie
[…] Just read THIS ARTICLE saying that Ralph Messer isn’t even Jewish. As if this wasn’t already a huge mess. […]
February 2, 2012 at 10:47 pm
celamb2007
This has to be the most ridiculous thing I’ve ever seen. Bad enough people will literally stand and cheer for it but then it shifts into borderline worship. No, ACTUAL worship; there’s no other name for people carrying you around a building in a chair, with a “centuries old scroll” in your hands. It’s more nonsense from the Eddie Long camp and I’m curious to see what stuff comes up next.
February 3, 2012 at 6:27 am
Gev
Messer isn’t even a Messianic Jew nor a part of the Messianic movement: http://roshpinaproject.com/2012/02/02/messer-crowns-eddie-long-as-king/
February 3, 2012 at 6:41 am
Rabbi Ralph Messer Is A Stunt Queen; Not Even A REAL Rabbi! « The Luckey Star
[…] Source […]
February 3, 2012 at 10:13 am
Robert Duvais.
Well done. Great blog today and good job with the research.
February 3, 2012 at 10:44 am
beebee1
Thank you so much for pointing out the truth about both of these shysters. Shame on them!
February 3, 2012 at 12:26 pm
Kevin T. Keith (@KTKeith)
I don’t even know who these people are, or what prompted this. The ceremony is laughable, and becomes even more pathetic when the bogus religious references are parsed out. Thanks for that link.
But I’ll point out just a couple more things that the religious scholar didn’t touch on. Among the weird numerology, Messer notes that there are “22 letters in the Hebrew alphabet, there are 22 pairs of chromosomes in the human body – the 23rd was added by man, there are 22 amino acids”. In fact he’s right about the Hebrew alphabet (I had to look it up). But the rest is fucking gibberish.
I can’t possibly imagine what he means by saying that “the 23rd [chromosome pair] was added”. There are unambiguously 23 pairs of chromosomes in the typical human, and they are all acquired through the standard process of sexual reproduction. (The sex chromosomes – the “X” and “Y” chromosomes that determine sexual differentiation – are commonly counted as the 23rd pair. This pair is different from the others in that, in males, it consists of two distinctly different chromosomes – one X and one Y – while the other 22 pairs all consist of almost-identical copies of the same chromosome, one from each parent. But all 46 chromosomes, duplicated or not, are part of the standard human genetic legacy, as far back as the species has existed.) If he’s claiming that somehow modern humans once had only 44 chromosomes and genetically engineered themselves an extra pair, that would be the most astounding scientific discovery ever – and total horseshit, of course. If this is some kind of weird Garden of Eden shit – we only got “teh sex” after Adam and Eve – that doesn’t even match the story (Adam and Eve were clearly male and female, so presumably had the appropriate X and Y chromosomes). This is just fucking insane.
As for amino acids, there are 22 amino acids are commonly incorporated into proteins under direction by the genetic code, but there are many more amino acids, as such, found in the human body. Of the 22 “traditional” amino acids, only 21 are found in humans, and some biochemists argue that one of these should not be classified with the standard 20 that everyone accepts, because its coding and protein-building mechanism is very different. So, in fact, how many amino acids are there? Depends on what organism you’re talking about, which group of amino acids you’re talking about, and how you classify them. Any way you slice it, though, “22” and “human” can’t go together in this context (though technically he didn’t say that; maybe he really meant that “there are 21 genetically-coded amino acids in humans, plus an extra one in some methane-producing bacteria, if you count the two weird ones”).
Dr. Gafney, the scholar, also points out that Messer doesn’t give a source for his claim that “Jewish doctors say that, when you look in a microscope your cells, everybody, look exactly like Hebrew letters”. He could have done better by simply noting that it’s not true. Again, I have absolutely no idea what this could mean – human cells simply don’t look like Hebrew letters. I’ve taken biology, microbiology, cytology (cells) and cytogenetics (chromosome analysis) courses, and spent a fair amount of time looking down microscopes at human cells. And I’ve seen Hebrew script. And they don’t look alike! I wonder if he might possibly be thinking of the chromosomes in dividing cells – when stained black with a common microscopy die, they can look kind of like scribbly strings at the early stage of the process, but they don’t look like a fucking Torah scroll! This is beyond stupid – it’s just wrong. (Here, take a look: http://www.ptei.org/assets/HistoryofTissues.jpg Here’s a comparison of human chromosomes under a microscope and characters of the Hebrew alphabet: http://bit.ly/ytiHp7 Can you tell them apart? Can you spot the pair of chromosomes that was “added”?)
The reference to a “king chromosome” is also garbled. There have been some attempts to identify a genetic marker for the traditional lineage of temple priests (Cohanim) on the ordinary male Y chromosome, but this is not an unique chromosome, nor is it proof of priestly ancestry. (And I’m kind of guessing this guy isn’t really a Sephardic Jewish Cohen.) I’d almost let this one go, because this marker is sometimes casually – though inaccurately – referred to as “the Aaron chromosome” (after the first Cohen), but it’s still awfully confused.
So, aside from being fraudulent, offensive to other religions, ignorant, and a liar, it turns out this Christian fundamentalist huckster is also scientifically illiterate! Who could have guessed?
February 3, 2012 at 1:09 pm
Skeeter McClusky
Does anyone else recognize the impossibility of being a “messianic” Jew? The New Testament tells us clearly that in Christ there are no longer Jew or gentile. Otherwise, for you Christians who are confused by all of this, have you read your Bible? Especially the parts about false prophets and teachers.
February 3, 2012 at 1:39 pm
Mark F
A couple of us had an idea that he wasn’t Jewish. Thanks for posting to keep this lunacy of Eddie Long in check!
February 3, 2012 at 2:32 pm
indestiny
Pure Foolishness
February 3, 2012 at 6:03 pm
RenaissanceChristian
Rabbi is just a word that means teacher, is it not?
February 3, 2012 at 6:09 pm
RenaissanceChristian
1 Peter 9 explains about the royal priesthood of those who are born again in CHRIST JESUS.
It is sad that no one seems to see GOD’s Compassion in this.
I wonder, do your own lives stand up to scrutiny?
February 3, 2012 at 9:16 pm
Elder S. A. Kennedy, Sr.
Eddie Long is NOT a Christian!!! He is not a reflection of or a representative of Jesus Christ. He is a sham and con artist.
February 3, 2012 at 11:00 pm
Mark F
RenaissanceChristian, I see nothing here but a pedophile who abused young boys being touted about as some sort of ‘new messiah.’ That show had zero on substance an absolutely nothing to do with Christianity or Christian behavior. Eddie Long needs to be prayed for earnestly but to call this anything other than what it is, a sham, would be playing into the wrong hands.
This is not a ‘judge not lest…’ situation. There is clear cut evidence that he is a f-r-a-u-d and a wolf in sheep’s clothing.
Not trying to be mean-spirited here but this was ridiculous!
February 3, 2012 at 11:21 pm
RenaissanceChristian
Mark F: So, the truth has not been found out yet about the so-called pedophilia that occurred (after all, these young men were 16 years of age and older, so they weren’t really young boys, but old enough to say ‘no’). Also, Michael Jackson received more support from those in and out of the world than this man.
However, as a born again believer in CHRIST JESUS, I have to look to Scripture and what I was brought to is 1 Peter 9 and Acts, in which Gamelial states that one should wait to see if this is of GOD or not. None have, everyone (the majority anyway) rushed to judgement.
If you believe that Eddie Long be prayed for, then do so, and stop tearing down what at this time none of us know what fruit will come from this.
Finally, are you saying that the LORD cannot restore Eddie Long? Did HE not restore David? Isn’t JESUS in the business of restoration? I mean after all, HE, JESUS is the LIVING WORD in WHOM we who are born again are clothed (HIS Righteousness).
I am just astonished at the jackals tearing at this man.
February 3, 2012 at 11:24 pm
RenaissanceChristian
So Elder Kennedy, pardon me, but I would like to know just what Pastor Long did to you personally that would cause you to so vehemently and without hesitation declare that Eddie Long is not a Christian.
At this point, what proof do I have that you are? I don’t see love or compassion, I see something altogether different.
February 4, 2012 at 4:58 am
dena4yeshua
Renaissance Christian- As a Jewish believer I am appalled at this Ralph Messers false Jewish ritual and disrepect for the Holy Torah which is the Word of G-D. No man is to be lifted up, only Yeshua.
As far as Eddie Long (giving him the benefit of the doubt that he has truly repented) the Word of G-D says you shall know My disciples by their fruit. If he has truly repented and knows his Bible then he would know that he is not to be lifted up and exalted but to be prostrate before his G-D and that fact that he allowed such a thing to happen in his church shows that he still has a pride issue and the Word says that pride comes before a fall. He has already fallen once, you would think that would be enough to humble this man. Woe to him that exalts himself and mingles with false doctrine.
February 4, 2012 at 6:11 am
RenaissanceChristian
You said:
No man is to be lifted up, only Yeshua.
You mean there is never a hora chair used in Jewish tradition? What about hoisting the bride and groom on the shoulders and dancing around the room with them. Does that mean they are elevated above G_d?
Just asking so I can have clarity here.
February 4, 2012 at 6:22 am
» Some Notes on Rabbi Ralph Messer Bartholomew’s Notes on Religion
[…] same way, to Bishop Keith Butler of Word of Faith International Christian Center. According to a comment on another site: was there when they gave him the SCROLLS. The last time I was there theey were […]
February 4, 2012 at 8:57 am
Grant
Nuff said
February 4, 2012 at 10:36 am
eggontoast (@eggontoast)
HEY, that guy believes in a completely different sky-monster than I do. I’m thoroughly offended!
February 4, 2012 at 11:02 am
Kings & Things « Madness & Joy
[…] you know by now, a Rabbi has Crowned Eddie Long Intercontinental Champ King. Okay, not a real Rabbi and it’s not a real […]
February 4, 2012 at 1:56 pm
Ron Cantor
Messianic Jews are united in condemning Messer’s unbiblical, embarrassing and disgusting misuse of the torah scroll. He is not one of ours. He is not ordained with any Messianic group and does not have connection with the US Messianic Jewish movement.
For more on this debacle and a point by point repudiation of the number of lies he spewed out, read my blog post: http://messiahsmandate.org/blog/315-rabbi-messer-crowns-eddie-long-king-a-messianic-response.html
February 4, 2012 at 2:52 pm
EDDIE LONG – IT IS NOT HIS FAULT! « Spiritual Side of Domestic Violence
[…] the words of Rabbi Ralph Messer, “a Messianic […]
February 4, 2012 at 6:10 pm
james
I just saw this about Ralph, check it out.
February 4, 2012 at 9:14 pm
hubbit
I finally had a chance to take a look at that 5:15 mark on the video, and now I see what you’re talking about.
Believe it or not, that’s not Scotch tape; it’s a reinforcement made by gluing strips of blank klaf (the parchment on which the scrolls are written) near the top and the bottom, to reinforce the stress points where the sections are stitched together. This is permitted, as it does not affect the top of the parchment where the writing is.
The video isn’t clear enough to read the writing on the mantle (the cover of the scroll, which he incorrectly calls the “foreskin”); but the lettering at the bottom of it would be a memorial dedication to someone or several people, usually to parents by their children. I suspect that if that family knew where the sefer torah they dedicated wound up and how it was used, they would be horrified.
February 5, 2012 at 12:49 pm
Bishop Eddie Long Crowned ‘King’ at New Birth Baptist Church (Video) | JAYFORCE
[…] has been going on with this guy, now he’s crowned “King” by what appears to be a fake Rabbi of some sorts. The video gets really wild around the 7:00 minute […]
February 5, 2012 at 6:59 pm
Toldu So
Here is a Video of Ralph Messer wrapping evangelist Paula White in a Torah Scroll
February 5, 2012 at 7:19 pm
Katie
I attend a real Messianic Synogogue and we have a real Rabbi, Ira, who loves the Lord and Yeshua. He is so upset by Messer’s actions that this past Sabbath, he asked us not to call him Rabbi anymore, because he does not want to be associated with this man who claims the same title. We support him 100 percent and will all stand for God with him and maintain reverence for what the Torah represents.
February 5, 2012 at 11:51 pm
Paula Coyle
I’m a Christian and Messer IMO (and in many Christians’ opinions) is also not a Christian minister.
He’s a charlatan and a fake. He spouted off so much nonsense about numbers and chromosomes and trash at the beginning my husband and I were just totally agog. HOW do people fall for this!? It is a travesty of eternal proportions!
Long looked drugged through the whole thing. It was utterly the most bizarre thing I’ve seen. But you will see a lot of so called Christians behaving in this way, almost as a matter of course. They believe that because God sometimes did strange and unconventional and/or unbelievable things, that if they do things that we all consider strange, unconventional, or unbelievable, means God is directing them or inspiring them. HOGWASH.
February 5, 2012 at 11:59 pm
Paula Coyle
I remember watching a video where a guy trained an actor to be a fake pastor in order to infiltrate a church and see how easy it is to get people to give him money. It was fraught with conflict of interest because of course he was doing it out of CONCERN for people being fleeced routinely.
Derren Brown, from the BBC takes on Faith Healers
http://www.guardian.co.uk/culture/tvandradioblog/2011/apr/19/derren-brown-faith-healers
See if you can find a copy to watch online or somewhere. It is worth it.
People are so gullible.
February 6, 2012 at 12:14 am
Paula Coyle
Actually here it is
February 6, 2012 at 3:05 am
Pakinpastor
2 TImothy 3 anyone? This is a sad time for anyone who would do such a vile thing. But the Word declared it long, long ago. So sad to see the adversary at work against what is Truth! I pray that the whole congregation may have their eyes opened to what is Truth and what is Long!
I am in pain over this…
February 6, 2012 at 6:49 am
Gev
Long has apologised but Messer won’t! http://roshpinaproject.com/2012/02/06/eddie-long-apologizes-to-jewish-group-for-misuse-of-torah-scroll/
February 6, 2012 at 8:52 pm
Peter Clausen
“Foreskin”…HA-HAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!!!! That says a LOT.
February 7, 2012 at 1:55 am
What a con artist!
Since you guys seem to be exposing the truth, I thought you should know. I’m including a video from you tube from popular messianic jewish singer/entertainer Aviad Cohen. Mr. Cohen was invited to Ralph Messer’s church to sing. He did. Messer decided to take up an offering for him. When the service ended, Aviad was told there was no record of it and to go away and never contact them again. He never received a dime and they are still using his music today against Mr. Cohen’s wishes and have never even paid a royalty.
February 7, 2012 at 5:44 pm
Site Admin
Thanks for helping to inform the public about Ralph Messer and his phony Jewish identity.
I wrote the following over at my site:
http://chizzukemunah.com/2012/02/08/messianics-christians-wrapped-in-torah-scrolls/
February 8, 2012 at 8:02 pm
Sarah
http://michaelrood.tv/blog/messy-ralph-messer/
“Hebrew Roots teacher Michael Rood responds to a video of a self-proclaimed Messianic Jewish Rabbi anointing Bishop Eddie Long, who recently settled a multi-million dollar lawsuit for allegedly molesting teenage boys.
“Michael sets the record straight on so-called Messianic Rabbis and exposes ‘Rabbi’ Ralph Messer as a fraud. Find out why Messer can’t read the Hebrew Scriptures and what he has failed to understand in the scriptures because of it.”
This response on the Messer kafuffle: “citing scripture:
“* Explains why Messianic Judaism and Messianic Rabbis are oxymorons
“* Teaches on the true meaning of the word “rabbi” and what Yeshua said about calling each other by that name
“* Tells us what Yeshua had to say about the man-made rules and regulations set in place by the Pharisees – the same rules and regulations that Messianic Jews regard today”
“If you don’t know the scriptures, you can easily be taken in by these con artists out there who are making their money off of the new Hebrew Roots movement; this is exactly what Messer has been doing,” Michael Rood explains.
February 9, 2012 at 4:58 pm
David
Ralph Messer is Jewish. His Father was a Catholic and his Mother was Jewish. They were raised in North Dakota.
February 9, 2012 at 6:20 pm
Pakinpastor
David, The Word says that one is not a Jew on the outide, but one is a Jew who is one inwardly. Circumcission of the heart. He may have Hebrew blood, but that does not make him a Jew!
February 10, 2012 at 4:36 am
Gev
Even more Messer messing about here as he surfs a croll http://roshpinaproject.com/2012/02/09/ralph-messer-from-torah-taco-to-torah-surfing/
February 16, 2012 at 10:10 pm
The heretical Word of Faith movement, the “little gods” teaching, and the rule of Apostolic “kings” (like Eddie Long) in the NAR’s postmillenial Kingdom Now « Christians United Against Apostasy
[…] Ralph Messer, the “Rabbi” Who Crowned Eddie Long, Isn’t Jewish […]
March 31, 2012 at 3:37 pm
zach
Messianic Judiasm is 2000 years old, not “founded in the 1960s”. Nor is it a “christian movement”. Also 300 year Torah scrolls are usually held together by scotch tape because of the fact that the paper gets old and breaks down.
April 19, 2012 at 4:42 pm
Eddie Long ‘crowning’: Why do black churches often put pastors on a pedestal? | The Grio
[…] tradition and the man performing this coronation “on behalf of the Jewish people” may not even be Jewish is enough to warrant scorn and derision, particularly among those who take their faith seriously. […]
May 6, 2012 at 6:09 am
social
Do youve got a spam issue on this web site; I also am a blogger, and I was questioning your situation; weve developed some good strategies and were searching to exchange options with other people, be certain to fire me an e-mail if interested.
May 6, 2012 at 6:10 am
click here
Oh man! This website is sick! How do you make it look like this !
July 30, 2012 at 4:05 pm
Eddie Long ‘crowning’: Why do black churches often put pastors on a pedestal? | theGrio
[…] any religious tradition and the man performing this coronation “on behalf of the Jewish people” may not even be Jewish is enough to warrant scorn and derision, particularly among those who take their faith seriously. […]
June 6, 2013 at 9:34 pm
vic
Most of you remind me of reading the Gospels, Pharisees & Sadducees, brewed of vipers!