Okay, it’s not just #GamerGate. This passage, from one of his newspaper columns in 1944, applies pretty broadly to online political discourse in all sorts of settings.
“The thing that strikes me more and more — and it strikes a lot of other people, too — is the extraordinary viciousness and dishonesty of political controversy in our time. I don’t mean merely that controversies are acrimonious. They ought to be that when they are on serious subjects. I mean that almost nobody seems to feel that an opponent deserves a fair hearing or that the objective truth matters as long as you can score a neat debating point. When I look through my collection of pamphlets — Conservative, Communist, Catholic, Trotskyist, Pacifist, Anarchist or what-have-you — it seems to me that almost all of them have the same mental atmosphere, though the points of emphasis vary. Nobody is searching for the truth, everybody is putting forward a “case” with complete disregard for fairness or accuracy, and the most plainly obvious facts can be ignored by those who don’t want to see them.”
1 comment
Comments feed for this article
September 11, 2014 at 3:17 am
lauredhel
Wow, is this ever hitting home for me today. I told someone, plainly and civilly, the facts about our parking law : it is an offence to park across footpaths, even in a driveway crossover, because it is dangerous for folks who use wheelchairs, scooters, prams, visually impaired folks, etc etc). I was called a dick, nasty, arrogant, small-minded, narrow-minded, and a variety of other things – because I did not accept that that is where cars are “meant to park”. My mind was boggled.
Weirdly, I was boggled far more by that one than by the person who told me that it was no big deal, I could just “take one step around”.